“But China”

This square needs only involve one word – China. Sometimes that’s all there is to it. No appeal, no nothing. Just China. This page also applies to “but India.” Any otter would do {1}.

Examples

If climate change is an existential threat do you support crippling economic sanctions and/or military strikes on China?

(NoahP)

Climate is a dead issue. China and India and N Korea brought us all over the line. We need to work on survivability.

(DavidS)

Objections and Replies

BAU. China is allowed to do business as usual—
☞ Incorrect. China has pledges and targets. One may argue they’re insufficient, however. This may not imply what you make it imply.

Empire. China can do anything, nobody can stop the empire
☞ Are you praying for a One World Government Force, by any chance?

Polluters. Start with the biggest polluters first—
☞ Behind your computer, you consume more energy than the average person on this planet. Also, bear in mind the average American uses three times as much energy as someone in China.

Small. My country is small and has zero impact—
☞ Every molecule counts. Every effort helps more effort. We are all in this together.

Notes

{1} Otters. Playful but mercurial creatures that has become a meme based on a pun with “other.” Othering is uncool. Don’t do it.

{} Deaths. Air pollution from fossil fuel kills millions of people each year. There is an incentive to move away from it besides AGW.

{} Tangible. When facing a claim about ineffective solutions, ask for tangible suggestions to improve our current international pickle.

{} Together. There are merits in watching for the alpha, but that does not preclude from being in it all together.

Readings

2021-02. Global mortality from outdoor fine particle pollution generated by fossil fuel combustion: Results from GEOS-Chem.

2020-10. Quantifying national responsibility for climate breakdown: an equality-based attribution approach for carbon dioxide emissions in excess of the planetary boundary. DOI:https://doi.org/10.1016/S2542-5196(20)30196-0

2019-10. Car Talk.

2017? Has China’s coal use peaked? Here’s how to read the tea leaves