“But Denier”

Victim bullying never gets old.

Examples

[IANC] [T]here is only one use of the word “Denier” – someone who denies the holocaust against the weight of historic evidence.

[TWITS] Would you like to point out anything there that says [Junior] is a “climate denier”, disagrees with consensus, or doesn’t value peer-review?

[PER] It’s amazing how many of those labeling skeptics of “settled science” doctrine “climate change deniers” are themselves economics deniers.

Objections and Replies

(Agree) Practically all of them agree CO2 is causing warming—
☞ You’re missing the A in AGW {1}. Minimizing the A is not far from pure denial.

(Climate) Who the hell denies climate—
☞ Climate denial implies denying some part of climate science so well established that the best explanation for that behavior is denial.

(Credible) Anyone who says the D word isn’t credible—
☞ Most of the times credibility isn’t related to tone, dear Hall Monitor.

(Labeling) Using labels is juvenile and demonizing—
☞ Humans communicate using categories. Labeling is here to stay.

(Nazism) The D word connotes Holocaust denial—
☞ The first usage referred to atheists and materialists.

(Self-label) I prefer that other epithet—
☞ Good for you. To me you still are a contrarian {2}.

(Unscientific) Scientists don’t use the D-word—
☞ There’s lots of research on denialism and its promotion by megaphones {3}.

Notes

{1} A in AGW. — Contrarians raise concerns about the anthropogenic contribution over Global Warming, either directly by outright denial or indirectly by minimization.

{2} Contrarian. — I prefer “contrarian.” Never had any real fight over it.

{3} Megaphones. — Contrarians maintain their own outlets to peddle disinformation about climate.

Resources

The Contrarian Matrix lists the main ways to undermine the A in AGW.

The Pillars of Climate Change Denial offers another model of the matrix.

Global Warming Disinformation Database, Desmog maintains a series of profiles and individuals invested in contrarian megaphones.

* * *

Further Readings

2021. Strictures on Labeling. [Post under construction]

2015-11. Global warming: How skepticism became denial.
DOI: 10.1177/0096340210392966

2012-12. Science denial: a guide for scientists.
DOI: 10.1016/j.tim.2012.10.002

2007-02. Denialists’ Deck of Cards: An Illustrated Taxonomy of Rhetoric Used to Frustrate Consumer Protection Efforts. http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.962462